Livestock Research Innovation Corporation
  • About
    • About LRIC
    • Board
    • Staff
    • International Research Advisory Committee
    • Emerging Issues Committee
    • Annual Reports
    • LRIC Disclaimer
  • Research
    • Priorities by Sector
    • Ontario Livestock Research Priorities
    • OMAFRA Research Priorities
    • Research Scouts
  • Innovation
    • News
    • Newsletter
    • Early Faculty Mentorship Program
    • Horizon Series - White Papers
    • Getting Research Into Practice Podcasts
  • Resources
    • Funding Opportunities
    • Livestock Importance
    • Reports & Materials
    • Events
  • Membership
    • Why LRIC
    • Founding Members
    • Partner Members
  • Contact Us
Report card listing grades on a paper

Livestock in balance

Commentary by Mike McMorris, LRIC CEO, February 2022

Balance can refer to having elements in the correct proportions. Balance seems in short supply these days; look at the current pandemic. The world is failing pretty badly at balance with only 10% of the African population vaccinated, over 80% in Canada. 

This matters because the risk is globally shared as unvaccinated people act as a key reservoir and mutation ground for the virus. Shared risk but not a shared response. Within Canada and Ontario, we are seeing vast differences in how people define COVID response balance, with some seeking full individual freedoms, others setting highest priority of the health care system, while still others put community first. In reality, the right balance changes over time. For example, priority on health care capacity logically rates higher during a wave of infections.

What about balance in the livestock world? 

Here, too, it is easy to see imbalance. Just look at the many articles that claim (often falsely) the impact of livestock agriculture on greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions.  Just GHG emissions, no other considerations.  No one can question that livestock production contributes to GHG emissions. The sector has made progress, but to many who don’t seek balance, these statistics are met with skepticism because of the source.  To some, balance means there is no livestock production, though that position seems to ignore the food deficit that would be created.

Livestock production produces GHG emissions, but it also produces food. Highly nutritious food.  And in many cases, it does so by using resources that cannot be eaten by humans.  

What would a balanced report card for livestock production look like? I suggest that factors to be scored should include (in random order):

  • GHG emissions per unit of final product
  • Sound animal care 
  • “Sustainability” though that would need to be defined or broken down further
  • Impact on soil health
  • Contribution to the community and economy
  • Effective use of resources, including antimicrobial agents
  • Environmental impact (water quality, biodiversity)
  • One Health considerations (e.g. zoonoses)
  • Proactively implementing risk management (e.g. biosecurity)
  • Use of resources that have other direct benefit to humans

Who gets to create this report card? Who gets to do the marking? How would the weighting of individual scores change over time? 

No easy answers, but a topic that the livestock industry must tackle together.  

Recent Articles

  • You get what you pay for

    CEO Commentary by Mike McMorris, June 2022: I have heard industry, funding agencies and even researchers say that we need more cross sector (beef, sheep, etc) research. That makes sense; to date though, the record shows that available funding tends to be awarded to sector-specific projects.

    Read More
  • Reporting on what matters – the need for balance in the livestock sector

    Ontario Beef, May 2022: A statement many people in the agriculture sector have heard a lot in recent years is “you have to tell your story, or someone will tell it for you.”  When it comes to climate change, greenhouse gas emissions and the environment, the livestock story is definitely being told – but much as they might try, it’s not by the industry itself. 

    Read More
  • News release: LRIC names Early Career Research Award recipients

    June 13, 2022: Three researchers from the University of Guelph are sharing the first-ever Early Career Research Award, announced by Livestock Research Innovation Corporation (LRIC), with each receiving $25,000 towards their innovative research programs.

    Read More
Show All
Login

/ / Unsubscribe / Powered by Seamless™

2022 © Livestock Research Innovation Corporation

Guelph, Ontario info@livestockresearch.ca Mike - 519 766 5464 or Jean - 519 767 8583